Why I still have concerns about Edinburgh’s proposed “Garden Tax”.


Having been a Councillor for 11 months I know that where Council policy is concerned the devil is always in the detail. This is particularly true of the plan to charge Edinburgh residents for the collection of garden waste.

I argued strongly against this policy, but ultimately lost the argument. However, I feel that if people knew then about the policy what we know now then the implementation of this regressive charge could have been stopped.

A key argument against the “garden tax” is the uncertainty around what will happen to garden waste from those that choose not to pay the charge. We now know that 67,000 households are predicted to choose to opt out. Although the Council does not expect any problems to arise from this, I don’t know anyone that doubts that there will be more fly-tipping,  a return of garden bonfires and the misuse of the other waste streams. Before anyone shrugs their shoulders at this, I know from work I have undertaken in Belfast that fly-tipped garden waste makes a significant contribution to culvert blockages, and so increases flood risk.

We also know that those that don’t pay the charge will have to return their brown bins to the Council. The cost of this, where the 67,000 bins will be stored and what will happen to them is not clear.

A further issue is affordability to low income households. Due to arguments I and others made, the Council has agreed to exempt those who qualify for the Council Tax Reduction Scheme. However, individuals will have to apply for this exemption cap in hand rather than it being automatically allocated. Indeed, this is expected to take the cost of administering the scheme to over £100,000.

I am therefore in no doubt that the implementation of this charge will come with significant problems and that many will find introducing this charge along with a rise in Council Tax is unacceptable.

However, we have to remember that the charge was proposed because the Scottish Government cut our Capital’s budget.  That is perhaps the bigger problem. Yes, the Council can always be more efficient but the underlying issue is a Government that has other priorities.

2 thoughts on “Why I still have concerns about Edinburgh’s proposed “Garden Tax”.

  1. I bought my house in Buckstone as a newbuild in 1978. There has always been a garden waste uplift. Before the brown bins it was 4 black bags a month. Never was it said that this was not a funded council service. The council tax for my modest brick semi has been upped to a ridiculous price, why? to drive me out of Edinburgh, out of my home? Because of austerity my income has not kept up with costs. On top of that I pay higher income tax on my pension, and for what, I see wastage and blatent selective preferences in spending by the council and government all year long. I have no choice but to pay this additional cost. Furthermore this city is being taken over by hotels and student accommodation both with their own agendas. Its time permanent residents in this city are given more consideration.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s